Today was the Cincinnati's first Board of Education meeting of the year, and Mt. Auburn residents along with Taft School supporters showed up in an impressive number. With over 70 supporters in the audience including mothers, children, residents, and business owners - the Board of Education seemed truly impressed by the support.
It was interesting seeing the discussion happening. Here is an overview:
After a long agenda of other topics, 1.5 hours, the meeting was opened up for the public to speak. So to begin this portion of the meeting, the superintendent read a prepared speech that they are closing Taft because of budget reasons and that the public should understand the difficult situation they had to face.
Then the public spoke, and they limited it 10 people of a list of over 30 who wanted to speak. These 10 speakers were powerful, they spoke with intent, with passion, with conviction. They spoke from their hearts and they made their point that it was not right to close our community's school that has been performing well and that has had increasing enrollment.
Then, discussion with the public was silenced, and the board was able to discuss these points and this is where it got interesting. People say to be color blind, but wow, the first board member who spoke (black) was extremely in favor of keeping the school open and she mentioned that it was not discussed enough and that the decision was made in a vacuum without board input. Then a second board member spoke (white) and she mentioned, it should be closed, its the best decision for the kids, period. Then three other board members spoke (all black) in support of the school. In a neighborhood that is 90% African American, there seemed to be subtle racial undertones present during the board discussion, the whites vs the blacks. Then out of nowhere to further divide the issue, the superintendent mentioned that another neighborhood, Hyde Park (our token prodominently white, upper middle class neighborhood) wanted to re-open their elementary school, and she made hints that made it clear - if they fund Taft, they would not be able to fund the Hyde Park Elementary. There was a roar from the crowd. They were far from pleased. Nonetheless, the chair of the board kept interjecting and tried to moderate the discussion and she actually did a good job asking the right questions, and keeping everyone in line.
And after the 1.5 hours of discussing about Taft, it looks like the Board of Education is really going to rethink the issue. One board member made a good point, it is their job to keep the good schools going, to find ways, especially schools that are on the track to doing well, and if they aren't make them do well instead of closing them! So time will tell what will happen to the school, but it was great seeing the community organized in action to support their local school and it really seemed to make a difference this time.
